Buyer Default on a Residential Transaction

Last week, we blogged about the consequences and legal options available when a seller defaults on a residential contract in Florida. But what happens when the buyer defaults? What recourse is available to the seller, and how can a buyer protect themselves from inadvertently defaulting on a contract?

One of the key issues for both parties is which contract the parties sign.  For most sellers, a standard contract for residential purchase is ideal, because it provides very limited reasons for a buyer to cancel the contract. Many buyers, however, may prefer to sign the FAR/BAR As Is contract. The As Is contract provides a limited time for the buyer to conduct inspections, during which the buyer can cancel the contract for any reason, even if simply due to a change of mind.  After the inspection period buyers that cancel are faced with losing the deposit or the seller filing a lawsuit for damages or specific performance.

Which, brings us to the next key factor in protecting a party from buyer default.  The default provision of the contract lists the parties’ respective remedies in the event of default, and may provide for mandatory mediation or arbitration to resolve a dispute prior to litigation.

First, many default provisions provide that in the event of buyer default, the seller may elect to claim the security deposit in full settlement of all claims arising from the default.  This is often the remedy sellers elect, but may not be enough to fully compensate the seller for his damages.  Moreover, a dispute over a deposit will ultimately result in a lawsuit in which the escrow agent is paid its attorney fees before any of the deposit funds are awarded to the parties.  The unfortunate result is that, in many occasions, the winning party is left with little or no recovery because all or most of the deposit was paid to the escrow agent’s attorney. Sellers can usually also elect the option to file for specific performance, but that is very rarely a successful claim in Florida.

In any contract for the purchase of real estate, a seller is best protected by making sure that the seller can elect to sue the buyer for all damages incurred due to the buyer’s default.  Conversely, buyers are best protected by limiting the seller’s remedies to retaining the security deposit in full settlement of all damages, and include a small security deposit amount in the contract.

As to mandatory mediation or arbitration clauses, mediation is often a cost-effective way to settle a dispute.  However, mandatory arbitration clauses can prove to be cumbersome, expensive and not in the best interest of a party.  Arbitration requires significant filing fees (far more than filing a lawsuit in most cases), is time consuming and expensive, with the parties paying both their attorneys and the mediator, and the decision can not be appealed except in extreme cases. Therefore, I usually recommend parties to agree to a mediation provision but to steer clear of mandatory arbitration clauses.

Therefore, we highly recommend that any party entering into a contract for the sale and purchase of real estate to contact a real estate attorney to review and provide advice on the contract’s terms before signing. Should you have any questions regarding the foregoing, we urge you to consult with your local real estate attorney.

Sincerely,
Berlin Patten Ebling, PLLC
Article Authored by Michelle Champion, Esq. mchampion@berlinpatten.com
This communication is not intended to establish an attorney client relationship, and to the extent anything contained herein could be construed as legal advice or guidance, you are strongly encouraged to consult with your own attorney before relying upon any information contained herein.
All rights reserved. This copyrighted material may not be re-published without permission. Links are encouraged.
 
 
SARASOTA
3700 S. Tamiami Tr, Suite 200, Sarasota, FL 34236   P (941) 954-9991  F (941) 954-9992
 
VENICE
247 South Tamiami Trail, Suite 201, Venice, FL 34285  P (941) 955-9991  F (941) 484-9992
LAKEWOOD RANCH
8130 Main Street, Suite 206, Lakewood Ranch, FL 34202   P (941) 907-9022  F (941) 907-9024

Did you find this real estate law content useful, but need actual legal council?

Speak to a real estate attorney!

, ,

Don’t Get Burned By Solar Panels (Or Other Leased Items)

More and more homes are running off the power of the sun these days. Renewable energy has become a trending topic and solar panels are beginning to become prevalent in the state of Florida due to positive environmental impacts and the potential to reduce large A/C bills. Selling a house with solar panels comes with…

Standard Or “As Is?” That Is The Question

While Florida law requires no particular form of contract for a real estate transaction, the FR/BAR Contract forms are the most utilized and well-recognized residential contract forms in Florida.  The FR/BAR Contracts, created and approved by a collaboration between the Florida Association of Realtors and the Florida Bar, include two Contract forms: the Residential Contract…

Getting Up Close and Personal (Property)

When real estate agents are out and about showing homes, those homes are usually staged, lived in, and/or full of furniture, appliances, etc. So when agents get the property under contract, what exactly is conveyed with it? The “As Is” and Standard Florida Realtors/Florida Bar contracts are useful tools and have been drafted by attorneys…

DON’T BE CAUGHT WITH YOUR PANTS DOWN

Have you ever represented a Buyer that literally waits to the last second to inform you, via email, that they want to terminate a contract?  As a Realtor, what are your obligations?  Generally speaking your obligation (as Selling Agent) is to deliver the written notice of termination (or signed Release and Termination) to the Listing…

Attractive Feature of AS IS Residential Contract

The Florida Realtors/Florida Bar AS IS Residential Contract for Sale and Purchase is the preferred form of Contract for many agents, in no small measure because of its very clear provisions on how and when a buyer may terminate a contract.  These terms are found in Paragraph 12 PROPERTY INSPECTION; RIGHT TO CANCEL. Paragraph 12…

Am I Bound or Can I Entertain Other Offers?

“Do I have a valid agreement or can I entertain other offers?” In this day and age, this a question that is becoming increasingly prevalent.  For example, you receive a call from a buyer’s agent and the agent indicates that their client has agreed to buy your listing at full price, with no contingencies, closing…

Don’t Cry Over Burnt Turkey!

In honor of Thanksgiving, we have a holiday themed fact pattern.  Buyers and Sellers are set to close on a property the Monday after Thanksgiving.  On Thanksgiving, the Sellers have their friends and family over for one last holiday dinner in the house.  Sellers also decide this will be the first year they try to…

Escrow Agents & Deposit Deadlines – Show Me the Money!

How many times do you see contracts with the Escrow Agent section blank or TBD inserted on the line for Escrow Agent?  Do Buyers always make their deposit(s) by the Deposit Deadlines?  This blog will address the Escrow Agent and Deposit Sections under the FR/BAR Residential Contract (the “Contract”) and assume the buyer’s agent is…

Tips to Take the “Fright” Out of the FR/BAR Contract Under New CFPB Rules

We know people seem to be spooked by  the new Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (“CFPB”) requirements that went into effect October 3, 2015.  Never fear, we have some helpful timeline tricks for your Halloween treat this year: Loan Application.  To insure that the Loan Application requirements are met, the Buyer has 5 days after the…

Misconception of AS-IS Contract and Disclosure

When a party sells a property, they are required to fill out a Seller’s Real Property Disclosure Statement (“Property Disclosure”).  This Property Disclosure covers a wide array of questions about the condition of the property and knowledge of facts that materially affect the property.  Many are unaware that these disclosures are mandated by Florida law. …

Major Differences Between the As Is Contract and the Regular FAR/BAR Form

The As Is Contract and Regular Florida Realtors/Florida Bar Contract forms are essentially the same with the following exceptions: 1. Heading. Of course, the inclusion of “As Is” in the heading sometimes draws concern and can create minor angst for Sellers since they don’t want Buyers to get the impression that the Property is substandard.…

SHORT SALE CONTRACT DEPOSIT DEADLINES – EFFECTIVE DATE OR UPON SHORT SALE APPROVAL?

Originally Published: 5/4/2012 With 2012 being the year of the Short Sale, you need to be familiar with differences in the contract forms being used in the marketplace. Typically, in a short sale transaction, we are seeing the Florida Realtors/Florida Bar (“FR/BAR”) As Is Residential Contract form (“As-Is Contract”) being used along with either the…
Menu