Buying Somebody Else’s Problem

We are frequently asked what happens when a buyer takes title to property that is occupied by a tenant. The answer: the new owner takes ownership subject to any rights that the tenant may still have to continue occupying the property, and also receives any rights that the seller had (for instance, the right to receive rent, or to evict the tenant if they are in default). As a result, there are a few issues that agents should consider when dealing with tenant occupied property. For purposes of this article, we’ll focus on buyer-side issues.

Start at the Beginning. A buyer needs to understand the nature of the tenant’s existing rights, and this requires a review of the lease that is currently in place. A review of that document will reveal the remaining lease term, the monthly rent due, whether advance rent or a security deposit was paid, and what maintenance responsibilities the landlord has, among other issues.

If there is no written lease in place, then the buyer needs to communicate with the seller and the tenant to gain an understanding of the above issues. Sometimes there is no formal lease agreement in place, and the tenant is occupying property on a “month-to-month” basis – other times, a tenant may be occupying property without paying any rent at all. In any case, these facts should be investigated before the expiration of any due diligence period in the purchase contact that allows the buyer to cancel for tenancy-related issues.

The Art of Negotiation. If the buyer doesn’t like the terms of any lease that is in place, or if they simply want to take possession immediately, all is not lost. They can attempt to negotiate a termination of the lease with the existing tenant directly. Obviously, there is likely to be some cost associated with that termination, and the buyer may want to try to pass that on to the seller. Again, this must be done before the contract has “gone hard,” or the buyer may find that they are stuck with a tenant, or with lease terms they aren’t happy with.

Removing Pesky Tenants. Sometimes a buyer decides to move forward with a purchase with full knowledge of the fact that there is an uncooperative or defaulting tenant in possession. That may be a good business decision or personal decision, but the buyer should have an idea of what it will take to end the tenancy. This scope of this article is not broad enough to discuss the mechanics and cost associated with removing unwanted tenants – a real estate attorney should be consulted to discuss the pertinent facts and assist in that process. Suffice it to say that this is a conversation that should be had before a buyer agrees to purchase the property, and take on the problem tenant.

What’s an estoppel anyways? Remember Ronald Reagan’s old adage “trust but verify?” An estoppel is the embodiment of that sentiment. In short, it’s OK to trust what the seller tells you about a tenancy, but only if you also verify information with the tenant. So, as a matter of course, a buyer should obtain an estoppel from a tenant which sets out the terms of the lease (remaining term of the lease, monthly rent, any escalations, etc), whether any security deposit or advance rent has been paid (the seller doesn’t get to just keep that, after all), the fact that the tenant is not in default of the lease, the fact that the tenant does not have any pending claims against the landlord, and the fact that the tenant does not have any right of first refusal. This document has practical importance because it affirms information that the buyer needs to know to make an informed decision, and it has legal importance because it prevents the tenant from later taking a position different than they represented in their estoppel.

Reinventing the Wheel? Smarter people than me have already thought of all of this stuff. In fact, they put a lot of it in both versions of the FAR/BAR residential contracts (see Paragraphs 6(b), and 18(D)). Those contracts, however, don’t cover everything that a careful buyer should consider – for instance, the tenant estoppel required by Paragraph 18(D) does not require a tenant to confirm that it has no pending claims against the landlord (and no buyer wants to buy a ticket to being named as a party to a lawsuit). Commercial contracts vary wildly in terms and requirements, and may not directly address tenancies at all. An up-front review of the buyer’s contract rights relating to tenants is necessary to ensure they are sufficient, and that they are followed through on.

Tenants can be great for a buyer or they can be an expensive hassle. In either case, consulting with a real estate attorney will ensure that a buyer’s purchase contract will properly protect them and that the due diligence that is needed in closing the deal is properly performed.


Berlin Patten Ebling, PLLC

Article Authored by Daniel C. Guarnieri, Esq.

This communication is not intended to establish an attorney client relationship, and to the extent anything contained herein could be construed as legal advice or guidance, you are strongly encouraged to consult with your own attorney before relying upon any information contained herein.

All rights reserved. This copyrighted material may not be re-published without permission. Links are encouraged.

www.berlinpatten.comSet featured image


3700 South Tamiami Trail, Suite 200, Sarasota, FL 34239

P (941) 954-9991 F (941) 954-9992


247 Tamiami Trail South, Suite 201, Venice, FL 34285

P (941) 955-9991 F (941) 484-9992


8433 Enterprise Circle, Suite 100, Lakewood Ranch, FL 34202

P (941) 907-9022 F (941) 907-9024


442 West Kennedy Boulevard, Suite 312, Tampa, FL 33606

P (813) 467-7500 F (813) 251-1662

Did you find this real estate law content useful, but need actual legal council?

Speak to a real estate attorney!

, , , ,

Da do Ron Ron Ron, Da do Ron Ron

By now you have probably heard of Remote Online Notarizations, commonly referred to as “RON.” RON is being hailed as a tool that will revolutionize the closing process, and some day it will. But for now, the process of conducting closings using RON is going through some growing pains as we all race to understand…
selby lights in bloom

Stealing Home

So the contract is signed, the earnest money deposit is in escrow, the lender has approved the loan, the survey is clean, the home inspection reveals no issue, and the closing date is set. What could possibly go wrong? You show up to closing only to find out that the Seller never owned the property! This scenario has…

Movers and Breakers

Moving day can be an exciting time for many!  However, the thought of moving always causes angst, frustration, and physical/emotional exhaustion.  To avoid most of these emotional and physical moving issues, Sellers and Buyers should research said issues and then eventually hire vetted and reputable moving companies. Moving companies come in all sizes (i.e., National to local) and shapes (i.e., service and costs). …

Survey What, Survey Who?:

A buyer of real property normally is required to procure a survey due to a lender’s requirements. This is not so when a buyer is purchasing real property using cash or private financing. We often see the preceding buyers attempt to reduce their costs by forgoing the cost of a new survey and rely on…

Standard Or “As Is?” That Is The Question

While Florida law requires no particular form of contract for a real estate transaction, the FR/BAR Contract forms are the most utilized and well-recognized residential contract forms in Florida.  The FR/BAR Contracts, created and approved by a collaboration between the Florida Association of Realtors and the Florida Bar, include two Contract forms: the Residential Contract…

Property Sharing: Yours, Mine and Ours

Many times property ends up having some form of shared ownership. Sometimes it is simply in the form of joint tenants or tenants in common, but sometimes more complex forms are involved such as life estates, ownership through entities or even by agreement (such as a co-habitation agreement). Over the years, statutes and common law…
Commercial Purchase with Tenants

Preparing Yourself for a Commercial Purchase with Tenants

While a SNDA and an Estoppel Certificate are usual and customary components to a commercial real estate transaction, their use may be foreign to first time buyers, sellers, or agents.  A “SNDA” is an acronym for a Subordination, Non-Disturbance and Attornment Agreement. Use of a SNDA most often arises in commercial real estate transactions in which there is one or more tenants occupying…

Does the Subdivision Require Your Buyer to Be Approved By the Homeowner’s Association?

Typically, subdivisions created in the last twenty (20) years now require buyers to be approved by the homeowner’s association prior to purchasing a property in the subdivision. This application requirement can be found in the subdivision’s recorded Declaration of Restrictions or Bylaws. The application requirement sets forth the application process and timing requirements.  Buyers purchasing…

Is Waiting on the Association Estoppel Delaying Your Closing?

It seems like lately it is more and more the norm that closing agents are waiting for the management company, or homeowner’s association, to issue the estoppel letter for closing. What can you do to ensure the association estoppel doesn’t hold up closing?  Make sure you get the management company or homeowner’s association contact information…

The AS-IS Contract And Disclosure

When a transaction is an AS-IS sale, the seller often insists that the property is in “AS-IS” condition in an attempt to reduce repair limits/credits and possibly shift the responsibility for determining the true condition of the property to the buyer.  It is well known that the buyer is typically given a specified period of…

Preventing Post Closing Issues

Many clients, their agents, and unfortunately some closing/title agents believe that the end of a real estate transaction occurs when it closes and funds.  Too many times we have seen post-closing glitches, oversight, or lack of follow-up lead to problems with the future sale of a property.  Over the last few weeks we have run…

Dealing With Entities As Buyers In Investment Properties

As most of you are aware, more and more investors are coming to this area to invest in distressed properties. The result is an increasing number of short sale contracts in which the buyers are entities (such as LLCs) rather than individuals. Typically, short sale lenders require the seller to provide a slew of documentation,…

Short Sale “Pre-Approvals”

We are frequently asked about listings being marketed as “pre-approved” in the MLS. We suspect this designation is intended to imply or suggest that there can be a quick closing.  We feel that the use of the term “pre-approved” can be misleading and lead to unrealistic or false expectations. Other than a pre-approval under HAFA,…

Fraud Investigation – A Top Priority for Freddie Mac

In previous blogs, we have discussed our concerns about short sale fraud and the warning signals to watch for.  According to Freddie Mac’s Mortgage Fraud Officer, Short sale fraud has also become the top priority for Freddie Mac’s fraud investigation unit as well. Per the attached article, recent trends that Freddie has been alerting Real…

Assignable Contracts & Specific Buyers

Please be advised that short sale lenders are getting very strict about approving the specific buyer identified on the contract. As such, lenders are carefully scrutinizing assignment provisions in contracts. Short sale lenders who are reviewing contracts (that permit the contract to be assigned) are kicking back the contracts more and more frequently.) Lenders are…

The Importance of a Municipal Lien Search

Performing a municipal lien search is crucial when purchasing property in this day and age. In many cases there are unknown or undisclosed fees, costs or other issues that will impact a buyer post-closing. In addition a municipal lien search generally will assist a seller in complying with contractual terms to avoid a default. Examples…

A New Buyer Can Be Substituted for One Who Walked

We have learned of a very interesting development with respect to Bank of America. Bank of America has advised that it will permit a new buyer to step into the shoes of a buyer who has walked away from a transaction.  Furthermore, Bank of America has advised that the process will not have to begin…