COVID-19 Closing Conundrum…

The impact of the coronavirus (COVID-19) on business relationships is still a huge unknown, and we are all aware of how much uncertainty it has injected into our daily lives. Fortunately, the good people at the Florida Bar and the Florida Association of Realtors had the foresight to consider an event like this when drafting the standard forms that are used in most Florida residential transactions – the “AS IS” Residential Contact for Sale and Purchase, and the Residential Contract for Sale and Purchase. Those forms provide a framework for answering the question that we’ve heard several times over the past few weeks: “Is this contract going to cancel because of coronavirus?”

Each version of the FAR/BAR contracts contains the following two provisions which speak to the issue of cancellation due to coronavirus:

5. EXTENSION OF CLOSING DATE:
(b) If an event constituting “Force Majeure” causes services essential for Closing to be unavailable, including the unavailability of utilities or issuance of hazard, wind, flood or homeowners’ insurance, Closing Date shall be extended as provided in STANDARD G.

18. G. FORCE MAJEURE: Buyer or Seller shall not be required to perform any obligation under this Contract or be liable to each other for damages so long as performance or non-performance of the obligation, or the availability of services, insurance or required approvals essential to Closing, is disrupted, delayed, caused or prevented by Force Majeure. “Force Majeure” means: hurricanes, floods, extreme weather, earthquakes, fire, or other acts of God, unusual transportation delays, or wars, insurrections, or acts of terrorism, which, by exercise of reasonable diligent effort, the non-performing party is unable in whole or in part to prevent or overcome. All time periods, including Closing Date, will be extended a reasonable time up to 7 days after the Force Majeure no longer prevents performance under this Contract, provided, however, if such Force Majeure continues to prevent performance under this Contract more than 30 days beyond Closing Date, then either party may terminate this Contract by delivering written notice to the other and the Deposit shall be refunded to Buyer, thereby releasing Buyer and Seller from all further obligations under this Contract.

That’s a lot to unpack. First, we need to decide whether the coronavirus is an event that is defined in the contracts as a “Force Majeure.” It isn’t specifically listed, but it would almost certainly fall under the catch-all language which states that “other acts of God” will qualify.

However, the existence of a “Force Majeure” event, standing alone, is not sufficient to trigger the provision. Section 5(b) states that a contract extension is only required if the “Force Majeure” event causes services essential for closing to be unavailable, including the unavailability of utilities or issuance of hazard, wind, flood or homeowners’ insurance. So far, that has not occurred (at least in Sarasota and Manatee counties) – closings continue unabated to this day, and those services continue to be available. Section 18.G. is a little bit broader: it allows for extensions of time in the event that performance is “disrupted, delayed, caused or prevented” by a Force Majeure event. It is at least conceivable that this language could be triggered, even while closing services are available – for instance, a buyer could be quarantined, which may be an impediment to a closing. That being said, closings are becoming easier and easier to complete remotely (even from quarantine!), and if the closing is able to be completed using some effort, the Force Majeure provision would likely not allow a party to escape responsibility under the standard contracts. For instance, online notarization of documents has recently been authorized in Florida, allowing closings to occur without an in-person meeting. So, except in some rare cases, if closing services continue to be available it is unlikely that contracts which are written on the standard forms will be subject to the Force Majeure clause, or will be required to be extended.

Of course, this situation seems to be changing on an almost daily basis. So what happens if closing services become unavailable in the future? In that event, Section 18.G. requires that closings be extended for 7 days after the Force Majeure event no longer prevents performance. That section allows the contract to be extended for up to 30 days after the original closing date, and after that period allows either party to terminate the contract without fault. The time periods in this section don’t appear to address the realities of the coronavirus epidemic. If the coronavirus proceeds to the point that the Force Majeure clause is triggered, it is certainly possible that the condition will exist for longer than 30 days. In that event, if parties want to bring certainty to their closing, they will need to amend their agreement to extend the relevant deadlines.

If you have any questions about your contract or the impact of the Force Majeure provision as it pertains to your circumstances, we urge you to reach out to your real estate lawyer.

Sincerely,
Berlin Patten Ebling, PLLC
Article Authored by Daniel C. Guarnieri, Esq. dguarnieri@berlinpatten.com

This communication is not intended to establish an attorney client dguarnieri@berlinpatten.com and to the extent anything contained herein could be construed as legal advice or guidance, you are strongly encouraged to consult with your own attorney before relying upon any information contained herein.

All rights reserved. This copyrighted material may not be re-published without permission. Links are encouraged.

www.berlinpatten.com

SARASOTA
3700 South Tamiami Trail, Suite 200, Sarasota, FL 34239
P (941) 954-9991 F (941) 954-9992

VENICE
247 Tamiami Trail South, Suite 201, Venice, FL 34285
P (941) 955-9991 F (941) 484-9992

LAKEWOOD RANCH
8433 Enterprise Circle, Suite 100, Lakewood Ranch, FL 34202
P (941) 907-9022 F (941) 907-9024

TAMPA
442 West Kennedy Boulevard, Suite 312, Tampa, FL 33606
P (813) 467-7500 F (813) 251-1662

Did you find this real estate law content useful, but need actual legal council?

Speak to a real estate attorney!

, , , , , , , ,

Time (Of The Essence) Is On My Side, Yes It Is…

Contracts are full of language that may seem unimportant, boilerplate, confusing, or just plain useless. Real estate contracts are no different. The standard FAR/Bar forms for sale and purchase of residential property, “AS IS” contracts, and even vacant land contracts all contain provisions that you see all the time, but rarely have to really address.…

When In Doubt, Write It Out…

We have been asked recently whether an agent’s email containing a counteroffer is binding. That’s an interesting question in itself, but it also opens up broader questions: what are the legal implications of acting as someone’s agent, and are there any “best practices” that can help keep an agent out of trouble? Generally, an agent…

When Estates Become Part Of Your Closing

We routinely get the frantic call from a realtor or closing party to address a title issue or incident involving a deceased buyer or seller, or even a prior party further back in the chain of title. Those inquiries come with the urgent questions: Can you fix it? Can it be done before closing? How…

Lending a Hand on Loan Approval

During these uncertain times, providing buyers with the confidence and security to move forward with a transaction is paramount. A well-drafted offer can lead to a smooth closing process while protecting the buyer’s interest in the event of unforeseen issues. Section 8 of the Residential Contract for Sale and Purchase (the “Standard Contract”) and the…

E-Sign Me Up

  Where would we be without technology? The current pandemic has demonstrated how integral technology is to thrive in the real estate business. Such a vast array of tasks can be done electronically: sending wires, signing closing documents, remote online notarization, virtual open houses, signing contracts, etc. When a buyer and/or seller signs a real…

All That Glitters Is Not Gold

The COVID-19 pandemic (a/k/a the “coronavirus”), has hit very close to home when it comes to homeowners being able to make their mortgage payments on time (or at all). Where many Floridians are being furloughed or laid off from their employment, there is increasing anxiety over how that 1st of the month mortgage payment is…

Commercial Leases & the COVID-19 Pandemic

Many of you have asked us about acquaintances, friends, or family members who cannot pay rent due to COVID-19. Some have been forced to shut down, others who remain in business simply cannot pay their bills. What is a tenant supposed to do? Consider the following: Some tenants may want to just stop paying rent.…

Da do Ron Ron Ron, Da do Ron Ron

By now you have probably heard of Remote Online Notarizations, commonly referred to as “RON.” RON is being hailed as a tool that will revolutionize the closing process, and some day it will. But for now, the process of conducting closings using RON is going through some growing pains as we all race to understand…

Your COVID-19 Closing Related Questions, answered by Berlin Patten Ebling

We know you are all tired of receiving COVID-19 related bulletins, but due to the flood of questions we have received on the topic, we felt that this would be a useful and timely topic. This Q&A will answer some of the most common questions we have received over the last few days. We will…

Coronavirus (COVID-19): Is your closing at risk?

The team at Berlin Patten Ebling, PLLC is extremely sensitive to the impacts of the coronavirus (COVID-19). The effects of COVID-19 have prevented or delayed performance across virtually all sectors. Fortunately, we have yet to see very little impact to the local real estate industry and we are still seeing robust market activity, great attendance…

Lien Back…

  Did you know that Florida law allows municipalities to put a lien against property without actually recording the lien until they feel like it? And if these liens are not recorded at the time a buyer purchases the property, they will not show up in a standard title search. That means a buyer may…

Homestead Exemption Revocation: Welcome to Florida, Now Pay the Tax Man!

  Knock, knock, BOOM…this is the sound you hear when opening a notice of tax lien from your local property appraiser. The property appraiser’s letter states that you have 30 days to pay taxes, penalties, and interest, or there will be a tax lien filed on your home. There must be some mistake…how did this…

I Love You…Now Sign This!

  It’s that time of year again. Love is in the air, and spouses all over the state of Florida are scrambling to come up with the perfect way to show their significant other that they love and appreciate them. For far too long, spouses have stuck to the same unimaginative and uninspiring routine of…
selby lights in bloom

Stealing Home

So the contract is signed, the earnest money deposit is in escrow, the lender has approved the loan, the survey is clean, the home inspection reveals no issue, and the closing date is set. What could possibly go wrong? You show up to closing only to find out that the Seller never owned the property! This scenario has…

Relocation to Florida: Looking to your Future, Leaving your Past

We all know about the snowbird, the retiree, the investor, the tourist who asks the question: how do I relocate to Florida, how do I become a resident? Beyond the weather and lifestyle, there are obvious reasons why people want to make that move, including the lack of Florida income and estate taxes, exemptions for property…

Standard Or “As Is?” That Is The Question

While Florida law requires no particular form of contract for a real estate transaction, the FR/BAR Contract forms are the most utilized and well-recognized residential contract forms in Florida.  The FR/BAR Contracts, created and approved by a collaboration between the Florida Association of Realtors and the Florida Bar, include two Contract forms: the Residential Contract…

Property Sharing: Yours, Mine and Ours

Many times property ends up having some form of shared ownership. Sometimes it is simply in the form of joint tenants or tenants in common, but sometimes more complex forms are involved such as life estates, ownership through entities or even by agreement (such as a co-habitation agreement). Over the years, statutes and common law…

It’s Not Over Until It’s Really Over…Selling Real Estate After A Divorce

As you all know, real estate professionals constantly wear an abundance of different “hats.” Working in the real estate world demands that real estate professionals have at least a minimal understanding of a variety of topics including, but not limited to, family law, wills, trusts and estates. Even with divorce rates slightly declining, it is…

When Is It Critical To Review Your Estate Plan, and Why?

Just like other important life tasks, your estate plan deserves your time and attention. It’s important that you work with us to review your estate plan at least once a year. Think of this as your estate plan’s annual physical exam, and remember-prevention is the best cure. An annual exam isn’t necessarily the only time…

Color Of Authority To Sign Listing Agreements & Contracts

A contract (which, for purposes of this Blog shall focus on Listing Agreements and Residential Contracts For Sale and Purchase), is only as good as the authority of the Seller and/or Buyer to sign them. Many times, I receive calls from agents asking who has authority to sign the Listing Agreement, and then the Contract…

Insurance Considerations as Hurricane Dorian Approaches

As Florida braces for the possible threat of Hurricane Dorian, we encourage you to take all necessary precautions to ready your loved ones and homes for potential impact. If you are purchasing property, or representing a buyer of a property, that is set to close in the near future, we urge you to contact your…

No Leaks, No Damages, No Problems!

  Congratulations!  Your client entered into a new Standard FARBAR Contract on the purchase of a single family home in Sarasota.  The only contingencies are inspections and marketable title. Your client immediately hires a professional home inspector to conduct their home inspection.  During the Inspection Period the home inspector provides a “clean” report only notating…

The Repair Escrow Agreement: Having Your Cake and Eating It Too

In Florida, more likely than not a buyer will identify his or her requests for repairs early in a real property transaction and prior to closing pursuant to the standard FAR/BAR contractual provisions with little fanfare. Nonetheless, as in life and in realty, there are unforeseen circumstances where a closing extension would be difficult and…

I See Dead People (On Title)!

There are endless reasons for property owners to make the decision to sell their property. Unfortunately, one of the most common motivating factors is the passing away of an owner of the property. On top of everything that goes along with the death of a loved one, the last thing a Seller needs or wants…

“Options? We All Got ‘Em, We All Want ‘Em, What Do We Do With Them?”

We see option contracts for real estate purchases frequently, and we run into problems with those contracts just as frequently. In this blog we’ll go over what option contracts are, what they require to be effective, and we’ll identify some common pitfalls. An option contract is a promise by the owner of property to sell…

New Construction, Review Before You Execute

  New construction agreements can be extremely complicated and it is important that the buyer have a thorough understanding of the contract and terms prior to executing.  The construction agreements provided by developers are typically one sided and do very little to protect the buyer/owner in the event that an issue should arise.  It is…
Real Estate Firm

Your Condo Purchase-Treat It As An Investment

Condominium purchases by their nature involve property rights that are more complicated than typical single family lots or properties.  We have written several blog articles relating to investigations that buyers and their realtors should undertake prior to their purchase (links are included at the end of this blog). It is said that ownership of real…

Check Out My Title While BPE Resolves It!

One of the most frequent questions we receive from realtors involves the status of title to the property. The answer to the question “how is title” can be a source of great anxiety or a source of great relief. As a result, most people involved in any real estate transaction want the answer to that…

Not Quite Sure When A Contingency Ends? Read This!

We are fortunate to have holidays and weekends to provide us with time for relaxation, fun times with friends and family, and time away from work to recharge. Legal holidays and weekends follow a different rule for contract contingency deadlines. Throughout this week and into the weekend, while most of us will be celebrating the…

Balancing a Closing with Summer Vacation

During the summer when everyone is jet-setting on vacation, and year round as part time residents move in and out of Florida, we experience an increasing amount of closings where one or both parties cannot be physically present on the day of closing.  As this is a common occurrence, there are many ways to accomplish…

Breaking News! “RON” Remote Online Notarization is coming to Florida

  The much-anticipated remote online notarization (“RON”), is set to arrive in Florida as of January 1, 2020. Florida will join the ranks of twenty-three other states that have either passed or have pending bills that allow online notaries to perform notarizations anywhere in the world (Alabama, Florida, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi,…

Hurricane Season: The Good, The Bad and Still Closing

Often, parties seeking to buy and sell real property only concern themselves with Florida’s Selling Season and do not take into consideration the other season – Hurricane Season.  Florida’s Hurricane Season is kicking off and now that Hurricane Irma is approximately two-years in the rearview mirror, Berlin Patten Ebling would like to remind our buyers…

Look Before You Leap…Into A New Listing!

Real estate transactions can often be quite complicated and confusing for even the most savvy of Sellers and their agents. You would think that the most basic and straightforward step in the process would be determining who are the owners and who has the authority to convey the property and sign related paperwork, such as…

LOOK BOTH WAYS BEFORE YOU WALK AWAY FROM A DEAL

While it may not happen often, on occasion we have experienced situations where one of the parties “walks” from the transaction.  In this instance, the buyer or seller is often left in a difficult position and wondering what remedies they may have against the breaching party, if any.  A well drafted contract will typically set-forth…

Foreign Buyers & Sellers-Speaking Their Language

In Florida we are fortunate to have many foreign buyers and sellers of real estate. Sometimes they show up on a realtor’s threshold and are ready to purchase a property to use as an investment, or a vacation home, or a reason to remove their money from their home country, or to house their children…

Getting Up Close and Personal (Property)

When real estate agents are out and about showing homes, those homes are usually staged, lived in, and/or full of furniture, appliances, etc. So when agents get the property under contract, what exactly is conveyed with it? The “As Is” and Standard Florida Realtors/Florida Bar contracts are useful tools and have been drafted by attorneys…

DON’T BE CAUGHT WITH YOUR PANTS DOWN

Have you ever represented a Buyer that literally waits to the last second to inform you, via email, that they want to terminate a contract?  As a Realtor, what are your obligations?  Generally speaking your obligation (as Selling Agent) is to deliver the written notice of termination (or signed Release and Termination) to the Listing…
Contract paper With Pan

Zero-Sum Game?

How many times have you received or drafted a standard Florida Realtors/Florida Bar (“FRBR”) Contract with the General Repair Limit, WDO Repair Limit and Permit Limit labeled as “$0.00”?  This happens more frequently than you might think.  There are some that believe that by simply putting “$0.00” in the blanks the contract automatically converts to…

CRSP-12 and CRSP-12 Addendums Debut

Originally Published: 8/10/2012 Effective August 20, 2012, the FAR-9 Contract will be replaced with the Contract for Residential Sale and Purchase (CRSP-12). In addition, the Comprehensive Addendum (FARA-10) will be replaced with the CRSP-12 addenda. Please see the attached link to the summary list of the changes between the FAR-9 Contract and the CRSP-12 Contract.…

IMPORTANCE OF OBTAINING NEW SURVEYS AND HAVING THEM REVIEWED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE FLORIDA REALTORS/FLORIDA BAR CONTRACT

Originally Published: 6/8/2012 The following are excerpts of a more comprehensive article previously published by Julie A. Horstkamp, Esquire, Berlin Patten, PLLC, Member of Sarasota Association of Realtors/Sarasota County Bar Association Joint Committee, and Chair of the Florida Realtors/Florida Bar Joint Committee. We receive a number of questions regarding the survey provision under the Florida…

Nonlawyer Assisting the Short Sale Seller: Ministerial Acts or UPL?

As you know, short sale negotiations (and negotiators) are coming under great scrutiny by local and federal authorities. There are significant new disclosures for non-attorneys, and now the Florida Bar is weighing in on the subject. In essence, various proposals under consideration by the Florida Bar suggest that a great deal of the short sale…
Menu