Deficiency – What is it and How Much Time Does My Bank Have to Sue?

Originally Published: 3/27/2012

When an underwater home is sold in a short sale or a foreclosure, the greatest concern is almost always over the remaining mortgage balance owed by the homeowner (known as a “deficiency balance”) and how long the lender has to try to collect it.  When a property is sold in short sale, generally speaking, the deficiency is the difference between the total debt owed on the mortgage and the sale price.  In foreclosure, the deficiency is, generally speaking, the difference between the total balance and the fair market value of the property on the date of the foreclosure auction.  Obviously, “fair market value” is a very subjective term in this situation, and banks do everything possible to show the lowest possible fair market value of property after foreclosure in order to maximize the homeowner’s deficiency amount.

One of the best opportunities to negotiate or settle the entire balance of a mortgage loan is during short sale negotiations.  Even though it is not always possible to settle a deficiency balance through a short sale, a short sale typically produces a smaller overall deficiency balance, and always produces a more specific deficiency balance.  Among other reasons, this is because it can take years for a lender to foreclose, during which time default interest, charges and attorney fees continue to accrue on the underlying debt at a fairly significant rate.  In addition, the sale price for a private property in short sale is usually higher than the value of the property to the bank in foreclosure.

The most common question homeowners ask is: “How much time does the lender have to come after me for the deficiency?”  The answer is in the statute of limitations, which is five years in Florida.  But, five years from what date?  Many people think it is five years from the date they stop making mortgage payments.  This is not true.  A bank cannot even sue a homeowner to obtain a deficiency judgment until after the deficiency amount has been determined.

Depending on which route the borrower has elected to take, the five year statute of limitations begins to run either (a) from the date the property is voluntarily sold in a short sale or (b) from the auction sale date in a foreclosure.  In other words, the bank has five years from the date of any sale, be it voluntary or through foreclosure, to sue the borrower for the balance owed on a mortgage debt.  And, if the bank gets a judgment against the borrower following a successful foreclosure, the judgment can be collected for 10 years and renewed for one additional 10 year period. This means that a borrower could be haunted by a defaulted mortgage for more than 25 years.

One of the greatest advantages to a short sale (in addition to better opportunities to negotiate the deficiency balance) is that, generally speaking, a short sale will start the clock on the statute of limitations for the bank to sue for the deficiency balance much sooner than a foreclosure, which can take years to complete.

For these reasons, among many others, completing a short sale generally produces a better result than a foreclosure over the long term.  However, any borrower should consult with a real estate attorney before choosing any course of action, as there are always exceptions to any general rule.

Did you find this real estate law content useful, but need actual legal counsel?

Speak to a real estate attorney!

, , , , , , ,

“Save Our Homes” And Portability

  On Election Day a couple weeks ago, Florida Amendment 5 was approved with strong support. This amendment extends the period during which property owners in Florida may transfer their accrued “Save Our Homes” benefit to a new homestead from two to three years. Beginning January 1, 2021, an owner of homestead property will now…

Home Inspection Reports: A Life Isn’t Fair Teaching Moment

Mel and Dani are your typical first-time homebuyers. They have scrapped and saved for years to accumulate their earnest money escrow deposit and mortgage down payment. To keep down costs, Dani convinced Mel a home inspection was not necessary because the lender was performing a 4 point inspection. As a result, their contractual due diligence…

Prepare Your Buyer/Borrower for the Closing

  With the volume of closings that we have, we handle a lot of different personalities, situations, and behaviors when we go through our closing process. Being aware of these in advance, and perhaps trying to get ahead of the issues, can sometimes make the difference between a happy closing and a dramatic one. 1.…

Congratulations On Your Loan Approval… Now What?

Paragraph 8 FINANCING in both the “AS IS” and the “Standard” FR/BAR Contract* is the section of the Contract dealing with financing of a purchase by a Buyer. The purpose of seeking financing is to obtain approval for a loan, thereby permitting the Buyer to close on the Contract. This is defined under the Contract…

Runaway Buyers: Seller’s Options When Left Alone at the Closing Table

What happens when a buyer leaves a seller at the closing table and it is not related to unforeseeable circumstances? In Florida, the FAR/BAR contracts are the mainstream residential transactional sale agreements and they generally provide the parties with a reasonable expectation of their rights and remedies upon a buyer or seller default. When Johnny…

Commercial Leases & the COVID-19 Pandemic

Many of you have asked us about acquaintances, friends, or family members who cannot pay rent due to COVID-19. Some have been forced to shut down, others who remain in business simply cannot pay their bills. What is a tenant supposed to do? Consider the following: Some tenants may want to just stop paying rent.…

Coronavirus (COVID-19): Is your closing at risk?

The team at Berlin Patten Ebling, PLLC is extremely sensitive to the impacts of the coronavirus (COVID-19). The effects of COVID-19 have prevented or delayed performance across virtually all sectors. Fortunately, we have yet to see very little impact to the local real estate industry and we are still seeing robust market activity, great attendance…

I Love You…Now Sign This!

  It’s that time of year again. Love is in the air, and spouses all over the state of Florida are scrambling to come up with the perfect way to show their significant other that they love and appreciate them. For far too long, spouses have stuck to the same unimaginative and uninspiring routine of…

Don’t Get Burned By Solar Panels (Or Other Leased Items)

More and more homes are running off the power of the sun these days. Renewable energy has become a trending topic and solar panels are beginning to become prevalent in the state of Florida due to positive environmental impacts and the potential to reduce large A/C bills. Selling a house with solar panels comes with…

Am I Bound or Can I Entertain Other Offers?

“Do I have a valid agreement or can I entertain other offers?” In this day and age, this a question that is becoming increasingly prevalent.  For example, you receive a call from a buyer’s agent and the agent indicates that their client has agreed to buy your listing at full price, with no contingencies, closing…

Delinquent HOA Assessments – Who’s Responsible?

Investors of a foreclosed property often ask if they will be liable for delinquent HOA assessments that came due prior to their purchase of the property from the court.  In 2007, the Florida Legislature chimed in on the issue by passing Florida Statute 720.3085, which states (among other things) that “a parcel owner is jointly and severally liable with the…

Fish in the Pool?! A REO Cautionary Tale

Recently, we encountered a transaction where a real estate investor purchased a REO property, and after closing, discovered tens of thousands in code enforcement liens against the property.  The buyer was never told of the liens prior to purchase and was fully responsible to pay the liens.  It turns out the liens were due to…

Foreclosures on the Rise: Clarifying the Statute of Limitations

In 2013, after the Florida legislature significantly overhauled the foreclosure statutes, new foreclosure filings in Florida nearly came to a complete halt.  Now, however, we are seeing an increase in foreclosure filings, as the banks have modified their procedures to comply with the new statutes.  With this influx of foreclosure filings, we are also encountering…

How Long Does a Lender Really Have to File for Foreclosure?

As any person involved in the real estate industry is well aware, there were hundreds (if not thousands) of foreclosure cases filed in 2007 and 2008 which were dismissed due to improper documentation or non-compliance with Florida’s foreclosure statutes.  Recently, many lenders have been re-filing these previously dismissed cases with better legal counsel or more…

FHA “Back to Work Program”

We all know how difficult it is to financially recover from a traumatic financial loss following a property foreclosure, or even a softer loss following a short sale.  In most cases, a homeowner who lost a property to foreclosure may not be able to qualify for a new conventional mortgage for up to seven (7) years after losing a home.  Under Federal Housing Administration…

Considerations for Successful New Construction

As many of you are now seeing first hand, southwest Florida is experiencing what we in the industry call a “construction boom.”  While we welcome the increase in new construction, it is important to remember that not all construction companies have fully recovered from the housing collapse.  In fact, several local construction companies filed bankruptcy and…

Time to Get Your Head Out of the Sand and Pursue that Short Sale

Most everyone is familiar with the terms “strategic default” and “deficiency balance.”  In fact, over the years Berlin Patten has repeatedly addressed the importance of getting legal representation in foreclosure actions, short sales, and debt negotiation.  However, we have seen countless instances of people choosing to essentially bury their heads in the sand and ignore…

Follow Up To “New Catch-22 In Short Sale Negotiation”

We have received tremendous feedback to our recent blog concerning lender(s) who are now forcing sellers to use auction companies to further market their property as a precondition to short sale approval.  Our previous suggestions to attempt to address the situation were (a) encourage the seller to incorporate language in their contracts to permit the…

The New Foreclosure Legislation is Now Law and Affects More Than Just Foreclosures

On July 1, 2013, many revisions to the Florida foreclosure statutes went into effect. While many of the new provisions are technical in nature and primarily effect attorneys practicing foreclosure law, the overall effect is a dramatic change in the foreclosures process and the rights of struggling homeowners. Also, most of the changes are retroactive,…

House Bill 87 And The Impact Of Florida Mortgage Foreclosures

As you may have read, House Bill 87 (H.B. 87) was recently passed by the Florida legislature and proposes to make significant changes with respect to the Florida Statutes regarding mortgage foreclosure actions.  As of now, H.B. 87 will become new law unless Governor Rick Scott decides to exercise his veto power, which seems unlikely…

Tips on Inspection Periods for Short Sale Transactions

As most of you have likely seen, the demand in today’s market for short sale properties is very high, with decreasing inventory and a large pool of buyers.  In fact, property prices are increasing in many areas because of this high demand, and short sale sellers are often receiving many offers – some possibly even…

Substituting Contract Pages

We have noticed an increase in a practice, that if not done with full and proper disclosure, could lead to substantial trouble for the parties involved, including civil liability, license forfeiture, or worse yet, criminal sanctions.  The practice involves changing and/or substituting pages to a fully executed contract.   While we recognize the reality that…

Dealing With Entities As Buyers In Investment Properties

As most of you are aware, more and more investors are coming to this area to invest in distressed properties. The result is an increasing number of short sale contracts in which the buyers are entities (such as LLCs) rather than individuals. Typically, short sale lenders require the seller to provide a slew of documentation,…

Navigating a Short Sale – Tips & Reminders

With the extension of deficiency waiver tax relief, we have seen no slowdown with respect to short sales, and do not anticipate a slowdown in the foreseeable future.  With that in mind, we wanted to remind anyone who routinely handles short sales to consider the following: Do not forget about how critical it is to…

Addressing Financing Contingencies

Under the Financing Contingency paragraph of the FloridaRealtors/FloridaBar-1 Contract and As-Is Contract (hereinafter collectively referred to as “Contract”), when can the Buyer or Seller terminate the Contract and is the deposit returned to Buyer? Prior to Loan Commitment Date, Buyer notifies Seller in writing that Buyer can’t obtain financing after using diligence and good faith,…

Issues to Consider Before Signing a Construction Contract

With the recent issues involving high profile builder/contractor financial challenges, and with the proliferation of buyers who are considering new home construction, we have received a number of inquiries lately about adequately negotiating construction contracts to best protect anyone who wants to build a new home. While there is no substitute for engaging a qualified…

Bankruptcy Follow-up: Short Sales Post Bankruptcy

Originally Published by Berlin Patten on October 12, 2012 With the proliferation of bankruptcy filings over the last several years, we have received a number of inquiries regarding the completion of a short sale following a bankruptcy.  Yes, there are lawyers who may suggest that a homeowner who has been discharged from a bankruptcy (and…

Removal of Second Mortgages in Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Cases

Previously, the general rule in bankruptcy was that if a homeowner wanted to “strip off” or remove a second mortgage, he or she could only do so in a Chapter 13 bankruptcy.  However, that has now changed. In McNeal v. GMAC Mortg., LLC (In re McNeal), 2012 U.S. App. LEXIS 9589 (11th Cir. 2012), the…

FREC Comments on Real Estate Licensees’ Involvement in Short Sales

The Florida Real Estate Commission met to discuss the unlicensed practice of law (UPL) and real estate licensees’ role during a short sale transaction.  The outcome of the discussion is in the attached announcement from FREC.  Please contact our office if you have any questions.    ORLANDO, Fla.  The Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) met…

Issues with Designating Seller as “Owner of Record”

Originally Published: 9/3/2012 One trend we have noticed recently is an increasing number of new purchase contracts with “Owner of Record” designated as the seller.  For several reasons, we do not encourage sellers’ agents to complete contracts with this designation, or for buyers to sign contracts without the full legal name of the seller listed.…

FHFA Announces New Standard Short Sale Guidelines for Fannie and Freddie

Originally Published: 8/22/2012 The Federal Housing Finance Agency has directed Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae to align current short sale programs into one standard short sale program and issue clear guidelines to service providers.  These changes will become effective on November 1, 2012. Per the FHFA, the programs being aligned are: Fannie Mae’s Home Affordable…

CRSP-12 and CRSP-12 Addendums Debut

Originally Published: 8/10/2012 Effective August 20, 2012, the FAR-9 Contract will be replaced with the Contract for Residential Sale and Purchase (CRSP-12). In addition, the Comprehensive Addendum (FARA-10) will be replaced with the CRSP-12 addenda. Please see the attached link to the summary list of the changes between the FAR-9 Contract and the CRSP-12 Contract.…

Bank of America – Enhanced Relocation Program

Originally Published: 7/12/2012 Bank of America is continuing to promote their enhanced relocation program (launched in May of 2012) that offers delinquent mortgage holders additional assistance with relocation expenses at the completion of a their short sale. Qualified homeowners who initiate a Preapproved Price Short Sale (without an offer) could be eligible to receive $5,000…

Home Affordable Foreclosure Alternatives (HAFA) Short Sale Update

Originally Published: 6/19/2012 Effective June 1, 2012, the following changes were implemented in the HAFA Program: TIME FRAME EXTENDED: The program has been extended to Dec. 31, 2013. The HAFA short sale can be initiated up to Dec. 31, 2013; however, the transaction must have a closing date on or before Sept. 30, 2014. ELIGIBILITY…

Cancellation of Foreclosure Sale by Filing Bankruptcy

Originally Published: 6/13/2012 In many cases, during the process of negotiating a short sale, the lender may have already begun foreclosure proceedings. When that happens, a race begins between the seller and the bank: either the lender forecloses first, thus preventing the short sale, or the seller completes a short sale before foreclosure. Many sellers,…

Florida Power of Attorney Statutes – Understanding the Recent Changes

Originally Published: 6/1/2012 In October, 2011, several changes were made to Florida Statutes dealing with the Powers of Attorney.  Some of the more material provisions and/or changes thereto are as follows: Generally speaking, a power of attorney executed in Florida that is to be used to convey real property must have two witnesses and a…

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Set New Short Sale Timelines

Originally Published: 5/26/2012 Please note that we have been advised that starting June 15, the Federal Housing Finance Agency has indicated that it will require Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to give a final short sale decision within 60 days. Fannie and Freddie must also respond to initial requests for a short sale within 30…

SHORT SALE CONTRACT DEPOSIT DEADLINES – EFFECTIVE DATE OR UPON SHORT SALE APPROVAL?

Originally Published: 5/4/2012 With 2012 being the year of the Short Sale, you need to be familiar with differences in the contract forms being used in the marketplace. Typically, in a short sale transaction, we are seeing the Florida Realtors/Florida Bar (“FR/BAR”) As Is Residential Contract form (“As-Is Contract”) being used along with either the…

“Collected” Funds

Originally Published: 4/25/2012 You might have noticed that more and more closing agents are requiring wire transfers from buyers to fund closings. Berlin Patten was forced to recently adopt this practice. Please note that no closing agent who has adopted this practice is doing so because they want to. Due to changes in banking regulations,…

Bank of America Process Changes

Originally Published: 4/13/2012 Several Florida legislature bills, including HB 213, are attempting to make Florida a non-judicial foreclosure state, which would allow banks to foreclose on properties in certain instances without filing a lawsuit or otherwise using the judicial process. This may preclude homeowners from the opportunity to defend foreclosure, which many experts believe is…

How Bankruptcy Can Backfire on Homeowners in Foreclosure

Originally Published: 3/12/2012 Many homeowners resort to filing bankruptcy in order to stop an imminent foreclosure on homestead property when no other legal options are available.  While, in most cases, the mortgage holder can still foreclose on the property, it cannot do so until the property is released from the bankruptcy estate.  This can take…

Backup Offers

Originally Published: 2/22/2012 Most short sale addenda have provisions for backup offers if you check the appropriate box. It is our opinion that, generally speaking, you should not check the box permitting backup offers when dealing with a short sale. It creates too many unnecessary legal and practical issues. Most importantly, many lenders and their…

Foreclosure Update in Florida

Originally Published: 2/7/2012 Several Florida legislature bills, including HB 213, are attempting to make Florida a non-judicial foreclosure state, which would allow banks to foreclose on properties in certain instances without filing a lawsuit or otherwise using the judicial process. This may preclude homeowners from the opportunity to defend foreclosure, which many experts believe is…

Cautionary Tale Regarding Wells Fargo

The Sarasota Herald Tribune recently published an article that stated that Wells Fargo had a short sale incentive/fast track program in place. The article, which is consistent with other published articles we have seen, suggested that Wells Fargo would be willing to fast track short sale approvals and even make payments to short sale sellers…

Foreclosure Update

As most are painfully aware, Florida foreclosures suffered tremendously last year after the discovery of apparent rampant fraud by both lenders and foreclosure attorneys in prosecuting foreclosure actions. Many existing foreclosure lawsuits came to a sudden halt, and new filings dropped significantly. As a result of this, along with the poor foreclosure practices of many…

Bank of America Short Sale Seminar Summary

The Berlin Patten short sale negotiating team recently attended a Bank of America Short Sale Seminar.  The following is a brief summary of what Bank of America advised its seminar’s attendees:  Short sales are about two primary things to Bank of America:  Hardship and net proceeds Investors are reluctant to postpone foreclosures as the buyer…

Response to Anonymous Blog Entry: Title Agents should still not be conducting short sale negotiations

On or about September 30, 2011, an anonymous reader provided a response to a blog Berlin Patten had sent to its readers regarding who can or should be engaged in the negotiation of short sales. While we debated whether or not to further comment on the subject (as the blog response did not really specifically…

Short Sale “Pre-Approvals”

We are frequently asked about listings being marketed as “pre-approved” in the MLS. We suspect this designation is intended to imply or suggest that there can be a quick closing.  We feel that the use of the term “pre-approved” can be misleading and lead to unrealistic or false expectations. Other than a pre-approval under HAFA,…

Short Sale Negotiations

We have been asked by several real estate agents to investigate whether or not a title company or title agent can conduct short sale negotiations. One of Berlin Patten’s contacts at the Florida Department of Financial Services, Bureau of Investigation, Title Services, responded to our inquiry as follows: “The license for a title insurance agent does not…

Fraud Investigation – A Top Priority for Freddie Mac

In previous blogs, we have discussed our concerns about short sale fraud and the warning signals to watch for.  According to Freddie Mac’s Mortgage Fraud Officer, Short sale fraud has also become the top priority for Freddie Mac’s fraud investigation unit as well. Per the attached article, recent trends that Freddie has been alerting Real…

Assignable Contracts & Specific Buyers

Please be advised that short sale lenders are getting very strict about approving the specific buyer identified on the contract. As such, lenders are carefully scrutinizing assignment provisions in contracts. Short sale lenders who are reviewing contracts (that permit the contract to be assigned) are kicking back the contracts more and more frequently.) Lenders are…

Berlin Patten’s Short Sale and Bankruptcy Services

Real Estate professionals are frequently confronted with listing a short sale property encumbered by two or more mortgages and a seller who is strongly considering bankruptcy as its “exit strategy.” We have struggled with that same scenario… working on a short sale for months, and then the seller decides to file for bankruptcy. At that…

HAFA Policy Changes for Servicers

Lenders’ inconsistent eligibility requirements seem to be the most consistent thing we have seen with respect to the Federal Government’s HAFA (Home Affordable Foreclosure Alternatives) Program.  The Federal Government seems to have taken notice. On August 9, 2011, the Home Affordable Foreclosure Alternatives Program adopted certain policy guideline changes.  The changes, we presume, are in…

The Importance of a Municipal Lien Search

Performing a municipal lien search is crucial when purchasing property in this day and age. In many cases there are unknown or undisclosed fees, costs or other issues that will impact a buyer post-closing. In addition a municipal lien search generally will assist a seller in complying with contractual terms to avoid a default. Examples…

Short Sales – Working with Second Lenders

Anyone who works with short sales knows that it can be very difficult to get short sales approved when there is a second (or even third lender). To successfully complete a short sale, ALL lenders (among others) must agree. The problem is that in many instances, they do not. In fact, we have seen situations…

A New Buyer Can Be Substituted for One Who Walked

We have learned of a very interesting development with respect to Bank of America. Bank of America has advised that it will permit a new buyer to step into the shoes of a buyer who has walked away from a transaction.  Furthermore, Bank of America has advised that the process will not have to begin…

Deficiencies and Deficiency Judgements

We spend a great deal of time counseling prospective short sale sellers regarding the advantages of attempting to pursue a short sale rather than allowing their property to go through the foreclosure process. Many people do not realize that the foreclosure process is a two step process. The first step is the sale of the…

Bank of America Realtor/Broker Listing Agent Certification – Questions and Answers

The new Bank of America Realtor/Broker Listing Agent Certification (the “Certification”) has fostered some significant concern among real estate agents. The most common questions and our comments/responses are as follows: 1. Question: Does paragraph 1 of the Certification mean that Bank of America will not pay a commission. Answer: No! Bank of America never paid…

Wells Fargo Short Sale Addendum

As expected, Wells Fargo has followed suit with Bank of America and has put out a new Short Sale Affidavit (attached hereto). Similar to the agreements recently published by Bank of America, Wells Fargo appears to be getting more aggressive in trying to curb flips and low offers and is now requiring realtors and closing…

Bank of America Document Warning

Please be advised that Bank of America is now requiring the parties to a short sale transaction to execute certain form documents before they will consider your short sale for approval. The buyer and seller will be required to execute a new addendum, and somewhat interestingly, the agents involved in the transaction will also need…

Nonlawyer Assisting the Short Sale Seller: Ministerial Acts or UPL?

As you know, short sale negotiations (and negotiators) are coming under great scrutiny by local and federal authorities. There are significant new disclosures for non-attorneys, and now the Florida Bar is weighing in on the subject. In essence, various proposals under consideration by the Florida Bar suggest that a great deal of the short sale…

FTC Issues New Rules for MARS

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has issued new rules that might impact real estate practitioners who represent clients involved in short sale transactions. The Mortgage Assistance Relief Services (“MARS”) regulations define anyone providing services which assist or attempt to assist the consumer in negotiating a short sale as a “MARS” provider. Depending on certain factors,…

“No Cost” Short Sales

You may have seen solicitations from companies announcing “NO COST” Short Sales that can be closed quickly, sometimes as quickly as 45 days. We suggest that you use great caution when engaging these companies or recommending these companies to short sale sellers. First, there is no such thing as a free ride. In most cases,…

Bank of America is on Board

Bank of America will be participating in Obama’s Home Affordable Foreclosure Alternative program starting April 5th. The HAFA program is designed to qualify a home owner and a price for the home in advance of the contract.  The Bank of America representatives will be going through an extensive training this weekend before the launch on…

Foreclosure Sales Moves to the Web

Starting July 14, 2009 Karen E. Rushing, Clerk of Court and County Comptroller, will offer a web-based service that sells Sarasota County foreclosed property on the internet. If you wish to participate in the Realforeclosure online service, proof of publication and sale fee must be received in the Clerk’s Office no later than 5:00 p.m.…

18 Month Moretorium on Home Valuation Code of Conduct

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac implemented a new appraisal rule starting May first, written by the office of New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo last year; however, critics of the new rule applied pressure before the July 4 congressional recess with the introduction of bipartisan legislation that would mandate an 18-month moratorium on the “Home…

Fighting Foreclosure

There are differing opinions concerning homeowners who contest foreclosure proceedings in an effort to continue to stay in their homes without making mortgage payments. A recent article in the Sarasota Herald Tribune offers one perspective. The article titled “Fighting a foreclosure may beat the alternative” written by Tom Lyons reads “Staying, it appears, can be…

FHA Changes Condo Rules

There have been many changes recently regarding the financing of condominiums.  FHA recently announced its newest guidelines for financing condominiums. Realty Times provided the following summary of these rules. Kenneth R Harney wrote, “On one hand, the rules allow lenders a lot more flexibility in reviewing condo project eligibility and documentation.” He goes on to…

New Appraisal Guidelines

On May 1st, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac imposed a new appraisal rule, referred to as the Home Valuation Code of Conduct. It is now coming under attack from the National Association of Realtors. The article read: “The intent of the rule is to improve the accuracy of appraisals by eliminating pressure on appraisers from…
Menu