Past due notice

Investors of a foreclosed property often ask if they will be liable for delinquent HOA assessments that came due prior to their purchase of the property from the court.  In 2007, the Florida Legislature chimed in on the issue by passing Florida Statute 720.3085, which states (among other things) that “a parcel owner is jointly and severally liable with the previous parcel owner for all unpaid assessments that came due up to the time of transfer of title.”  The statute appears to state that a purchaser at a foreclosure sale is just as liable for any delinquent assessments as the foreclosed owner was – obviously not a satisfying result for the buyer!  Some savvy investors, however, have noticed that many HOA governing documents state that the new owner of a parcel shall not be responsible for any assessments owed by the previous owner.

Predictably, HOAs have relied on the Florida Statute to argue that new owners are liable, while the new owners have relied on the governing documents to argue the opposite.  How can the conflict between the Florida Statutes and the HOA documents be resolved?  So far, trial courts have generally sided with HOAs and ruled that the Florida Statute controlled over any contrary provision in the association’s documents.
Enter the Fourth District Court of Appeals – the first appellate-level court to review the issue.  In Pudlit 2 Joint Venture, LLV v. Westwood Gardens Homeowners Association, the court was faced with an entity who had purchased a parcel of property at foreclosure, and an HOA who demanded full payment of past-due assessments because it was “jointly and severally liable with the previous parcel owner.”  The new owner pointed to a provision in the association’s Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions which stated that “the personal obligation for delinquent assessments shall not pass to [an owner’s] successors in title unless expressly assumed by them.”  The new owner argued that it had not expressly assumed the obligation for the assessments, and as a result, it had no responsibility for them.  The court agreed with the new owner and held that the Florida Statutes could not contradict the prior-recorded association declarations, and decided that the new owner was not responsible for paying the delinquent assessments.
What are the practical take-aways from the court’s decision?
  1. Be aware of the general rule that the purchaser of a property at a foreclosure sale will be responsible for any HOA dues that had accrued prior to the foreclosure (first mortgagees get a partial pass from this rule, and are only responsible for a portion of the assessments owed).
  2. Be aware that many associations have documents which specifically change that general rule, and that these documents will prevail over the general rule, especially if they were recorded before 2007 (there may be a question if the association documents were enacted after the statute – the court did not address that issue).
  3. If you would like your HOA to bind subsequent purchasers of property to a prior owner’s delinquent assessments, you may need to review your governing documents to grant that ability.

In the end, purchasers at a foreclosure sale should know what risks they are undertaking, especially if they are purchasing a property that is part of an HOA.  A seasoned real-estate professional can review the appropriate documents, and help you identify those risks. As always, should you have any questions regarding the foregoing we urge you to consult your local real estate attorney.

Sincerely,

Berlin Patten Ebling, PLLC
Article Authored by Dan Guarnieri, Esq.  dguarnieri@berlinpatten.com
This communication is not intended to establish an attorney client relationship, and to the extent anything contained herein could be construed as legal advice or guidance, you are strongly encouraged to consult with your own attorney before relying upon any information contained herein.
All rights reserved. This copyrighted material may not be re-published without permission. Links are encouraged.
 
SARASOTA
3700 South Tamiami Trail, Suite 200, Sarasota, FL 34239   P (941) 954-9991  F (941) 954-9992
 
VENICE
247 Tamiami Trail South, Suite 201, Venice, FL 34285  P (941) 955-9991  F (941) 484-9992
 
LAKEWOOD RANCH
8130 Main Street, Suite 206, Lakewood Ranch, FL 34202   P (941) 907-9022  F (941) 907-9024

Did you find this real estate law content useful, but need actual legal council?

Speak to a real estate attorney!

, ,

Fish in the Pool?! A REO Cautionary Tale

Recently, we encountered a transaction where a real estate investor purchased a REO property, and after closing, discovered tens of thousands in code enforcement liens against the property.  The buyer was never told of the liens prior to purchase and was fully responsible to pay the liens.  It turns out the liens were due to…

Foreclosures on the Rise: Clarifying the Statute of Limitations

In 2013, after the Florida legislature significantly overhauled the foreclosure statutes, new foreclosure filings in Florida nearly came to a complete halt.  Now, however, we are seeing an increase in foreclosure filings, as the banks have modified their procedures to comply with the new statutes.  With this influx of foreclosure filings, we are also encountering…

How Long Does a Lender Really Have to File for Foreclosure?

As any person involved in the real estate industry is well aware, there were hundreds (if not thousands) of foreclosure cases filed in 2007 and 2008 which were dismissed due to improper documentation or non-compliance with Florida’s foreclosure statutes.  Recently, many lenders have been re-filing these previously dismissed cases with better legal counsel or more…

FHA “Back to Work Program”

We all know how difficult it is to financially recover from a traumatic financial loss following a property foreclosure, or even a softer loss following a short sale.  In most cases, a homeowner who lost a property to foreclosure may not be able to qualify for a new conventional mortgage for up to seven (7) years after losing a home.  Under Federal Housing Administration…

The New Foreclosure Legislation is Now Law and Affects More Than Just Foreclosures

On July 1, 2013, many revisions to the Florida foreclosure statutes went into effect. While many of the new provisions are technical in nature and primarily effect attorneys practicing foreclosure law, the overall effect is a dramatic change in the foreclosures process and the rights of struggling homeowners. Also, most of the changes are retroactive,…

House Bill 87 And The Impact Of Florida Mortgage Foreclosures

As you may have read, House Bill 87 (H.B. 87) was recently passed by the Florida legislature and proposes to make significant changes with respect to the Florida Statutes regarding mortgage foreclosure actions.  As of now, H.B. 87 will become new law unless Governor Rick Scott decides to exercise his veto power, which seems unlikely…

Navigating a Short Sale – Tips & Reminders

With the extension of deficiency waiver tax relief, we have seen no slowdown with respect to short sales, and do not anticipate a slowdown in the foreseeable future.  With that in mind, we wanted to remind anyone who routinely handles short sales to consider the following: Do not forget about how critical it is to…

Bank of America Process Changes

Originally Published: 4/13/2012 Several Florida legislature bills, including HB 213, are attempting to make Florida a non-judicial foreclosure state, which would allow banks to foreclose on properties in certain instances without filing a lawsuit or otherwise using the judicial process. This may preclude homeowners from the opportunity to defend foreclosure, which many experts believe is…

Deficiency – What is it and How Much Time Does My Bank Have to Sue?

Originally Published: 3/27/2012 When an underwater home is sold in a short sale or a foreclosure, the greatest concern is almost always over the remaining mortgage balance owed by the homeowner (known as a “deficiency balance”) and how long the lender has to try to collect it.  When a property is sold in short sale,…

How Bankruptcy Can Backfire on Homeowners in Foreclosure

Originally Published: 3/12/2012 Many homeowners resort to filing bankruptcy in order to stop an imminent foreclosure on homestead property when no other legal options are available.  While, in most cases, the mortgage holder can still foreclose on the property, it cannot do so until the property is released from the bankruptcy estate.  This can take…

Foreclosure Update in Florida

Originally Published: 2/7/2012 Several Florida legislature bills, including HB 213, are attempting to make Florida a non-judicial foreclosure state, which would allow banks to foreclose on properties in certain instances without filing a lawsuit or otherwise using the judicial process. This may preclude homeowners from the opportunity to defend foreclosure, which many experts believe is…

Foreclosure Update

As most are painfully aware, Florida foreclosures suffered tremendously last year after the discovery of apparent rampant fraud by both lenders and foreclosure attorneys in prosecuting foreclosure actions. Many existing foreclosure lawsuits came to a sudden halt, and new filings dropped significantly. As a result of this, along with the poor foreclosure practices of many…

Berlin Patten’s Short Sale and Bankruptcy Services

Real Estate professionals are frequently confronted with listing a short sale property encumbered by two or more mortgages and a seller who is strongly considering bankruptcy as its “exit strategy.” We have struggled with that same scenario… working on a short sale for months, and then the seller decides to file for bankruptcy. At that…

Deficiencies and Deficiency Judgements

We spend a great deal of time counseling prospective short sale sellers regarding the advantages of attempting to pursue a short sale rather than allowing their property to go through the foreclosure process. Many people do not realize that the foreclosure process is a two step process. The first step is the sale of the…

Fighting Foreclosure

There are differing opinions concerning homeowners who contest foreclosure proceedings in an effort to continue to stay in their homes without making mortgage payments. A recent article in the Sarasota Herald Tribune offers one perspective. The article titled “Fighting a foreclosure may beat the alternative” written by Tom Lyons reads “Staying, it appears, can be…
Menu