“Up a Stream without a Paddle-Closing without Title Insurance”

The immense value of title insurance has been well documented. Generally speaking, title insurance provides three somewhat distinct, yet significant coverage’s:

  1. Fatal title defects that could cause one to lose their property altogether, such as fraud, forgeries, inheritance issues, or execution/signing issues;
  2. Defects that could require the expenditure of significant amounts of money to cure the defect, such as a missed mortgage, lien, or judgment; or
  3. Defects that could require the removal of all or a portion of the improvements on the property, such as encroachments into easements or setbacks.

As opposed to other forms of insurance, title insurance is purchased one time (usually when the property is purchased), and provides coverage to the owner not only for the period of time that they own the property, but also coverage that can continue to afford protection to the owner even after they sell the property.

Title insurance is so significant that most reputable closing agents will not even close a transaction without making sure that a title insurance policy is purchased to protect the parties.  But some closing agents do try to minimize the significance of title insurance. In fact, some even go so far as to discourage the parties from purchasing title insurance. The theory, in most cases, is that a title policy is not necessary, and if there is a title issue, the buyer can simply sue the seller to resolve that issue. In other words, the seller in essence becomes the title insurer (sellers should be VERY wary of transactions in which the buyer is not obtaining title insurance for this reason alone). That logic is fundamentally flawed for three significant reasons.

First, Section 9 (C) of both FR/BAR Contracts provides that a title policy will be purchased and paid for by the party selecting and paying for the closing agent’s services.  In other words, the party who is entitled to designate the Closing Agent is contractually obligated to purchase a title policy.   This is also common in most developer based contacts as well.  This is a material term that benefits both the buyer and seller, and the failure to purchase a policy is technically a breach of the contract by the party who is obligated to furnish the policy.

Second, trying to track down a seller, successfully sue a seller, and then recover from that seller is much easier said than done.  Many sellers are not local (some are even foreigners), and no seller is as financially solvent as a title insurance company. And ask any real estate litigator how many of their clients enjoy the process of costly, protracted legal action.   Logic would suggest that a claim to a multi-billion dollar title insurance company is a much more cost and time effective way to successfully address and resolve a title issue than a protracted lawsuit against a seller of unknown financial wherewithal.

Third, the warranties of title that a seller provide at closing do not cover many of your typical title claims.  For example, almost every Warranty Deed  that a seller delivers to a buyer at closing states that it is subject to restrictions, easements or other matters of record. In other words, if it’s a matter of record, such as an easement, then the seller is not responsible for it. If the house was built into an easement or setback of record, tough luck.  If the property violates a recorded deed restriction, too bad.

The merits of title insurance are simply too lengthy to chronicle in a brief blog. But the next time a closing agent discourages title insurance, ask for a copy of their malpractice policy. That will likely be the only recourse the buyer (or seller) may have in the event of a title defect.  As always, should you have any questions about title insurance, we encourage you to speak with a reputable real estate attorney.

Sincerely,

Berlin Patten Ebling, PLLC

This article authored by Evan N. Berlin, Esq., eberlin@berlinpatten.com

This communication is not intended to establish an attorney client relationship, and to the extent anything contained herein could be construed as legal advice or guidance, you are strongly encouraged to consult with your own attorney before relying upon any information contained herein.

All rights reserved. This copyrighted material may not be re-published without permission. Links are encouraged.

www.berlinpatten.com

SARASOTA

3700 South Tamiami Trail, Suite 200, Sarasota, FL 34239   P (941) 954-9991  F (941) 954-9992

VENICE

247 Tamiami Trail South, Suite 201, Venice, FL 34285  P (941) 955-9991  F (941) 484-9992

LAKEWOOD RANCH

8433 Enterprise Circle, Suite 100, Lakewood Ranch, FL 34202   P (941) 907-9022  F (941) 907-9024

TAMPA

442 West Kennedy Boulevard, Suite 312, Tampa, FL 33606  P (813) 467-7500  F (813) 251-1662

Do You Have 2020 Vision for Your Closing?

On behalf of the entire BPE family, we want to wish everyone a Happy New Year. Its times like this where it can be helpful to reflect on the prior year, and since this year is 2020 (presumably the year of “perfect vision”), let’s take a step back and reflect on those instances where the…

It’s Not Over Until It’s Really Over…Selling Real Estate After A Divorce

As you all know, real estate professionals constantly wear an abundance of different “hats.” Working in the real estate world demands that real estate professionals have at least a minimal understanding of a variety of topics including, but not limited to, family law, wills, trusts and estates. Even with divorce rates slightly declining, it is…

Color Of Authority To Sign Listing Agreements & Contracts

A contract (which, for purposes of this Blog shall focus on Listing Agreements and Residential Contracts For Sale and Purchase), is only as good as the authority of the Seller and/or Buyer to sign them. Many times, I receive calls from agents asking who has authority to sign the Listing Agreement, and then the Contract…

Insurance Considerations as Hurricane Dorian Approaches

As Florida braces for the possible threat of Hurricane Dorian, we encourage you to take all necessary precautions to ready your loved ones and homes for potential impact. If you are purchasing property, or representing a buyer of a property, that is set to close in the near future, we urge you to contact your…

No Leaks, No Damages, No Problems!

  Congratulations!  Your client entered into a new Standard FARBAR Contract on the purchase of a single family home in Sarasota.  The only contingencies are inspections and marketable title. Your client immediately hires a professional home inspector to conduct their home inspection.  During the Inspection Period the home inspector provides a “clean” report only notating…

The Repair Escrow Agreement: Having Your Cake and Eating It Too

In Florida, more likely than not a buyer will identify his or her requests for repairs early in a real property transaction and prior to closing pursuant to the standard FAR/BAR contractual provisions with little fanfare. Nonetheless, as in life and in realty, there are unforeseen circumstances where a closing extension would be difficult and…

“Options? We All Got ‘Em, We All Want ‘Em, What Do We Do With Them?”

We see option contracts for real estate purchases frequently, and we run into problems with those contracts just as frequently. In this blog we’ll go over what option contracts are, what they require to be effective, and we’ll identify some common pitfalls. An option contract is a promise by the owner of property to sell…

New Construction, Review Before You Execute

  New construction agreements can be extremely complicated and it is important that the buyer have a thorough understanding of the contract and terms prior to executing.  The construction agreements provided by developers are typically one sided and do very little to protect the buyer/owner in the event that an issue should arise.  It is…
Real Estate Firm

Your Condo Purchase-Treat It As An Investment

Condominium purchases by their nature involve property rights that are more complicated than typical single family lots or properties.  We have written several blog articles relating to investigations that buyers and their realtors should undertake prior to their purchase (links are included at the end of this blog). It is said that ownership of real…

Check Out My Title While BPE Resolves It!

One of the most frequent questions we receive from realtors involves the status of title to the property. The answer to the question “how is title” can be a source of great anxiety or a source of great relief. As a result, most people involved in any real estate transaction want the answer to that…

Not Quite Sure When A Contingency Ends? Read This!

We are fortunate to have holidays and weekends to provide us with time for relaxation, fun times with friends and family, and time away from work to recharge. Legal holidays and weekends follow a different rule for contract contingency deadlines. Throughout this week and into the weekend, while most of us will be celebrating the…

Breaking News! “RON” Remote Online Notarization is coming to Florida

  The much-anticipated remote online notarization (“RON”), is set to arrive in Florida as of January 1, 2020. Florida will join the ranks of twenty-three other states that have either passed or have pending bills that allow online notaries to perform notarizations anywhere in the world (Alabama, Florida, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi,…

Look Before You Leap…Into A New Listing!

Real estate transactions can often be quite complicated and confusing for even the most savvy of Sellers and their agents. You would think that the most basic and straightforward step in the process would be determining who are the owners and who has the authority to convey the property and sign related paperwork, such as…

LOOK BOTH WAYS BEFORE YOU WALK AWAY FROM A DEAL

While it may not happen often, on occasion we have experienced situations where one of the parties “walks” from the transaction.  In this instance, the buyer or seller is often left in a difficult position and wondering what remedies they may have against the breaching party, if any.  A well drafted contract will typically set-forth…

Foreign Buyers & Sellers-Speaking Their Language

In Florida we are fortunate to have many foreign buyers and sellers of real estate. Sometimes they show up on a realtor’s threshold and are ready to purchase a property to use as an investment, or a vacation home, or a reason to remove their money from their home country, or to house their children…

Six Things You Need to Know about Buying Rental Properties (#2 will surprise you)

When a Buyer is purchasing a residential rental property such as a multi-unit building, they often have many questions about their rights as the new building owner and landlord.  The Buyer may also wonder whether the standard FR/BAR real estate contract is the appropriate contract for them and what protections it affords them.  Below is…
Florida Title Policy Endorsements

Title Policy Endorsements & Additional Coverage

Buying a home is probably the most significant investment a person will make in their lifetime.  Protecting your investment is equally as important.  Title insurance protects a Buyer’s and Lender’s rights to the property as well as potential claims or outstanding debts from prior owners.  In Florida, The Office of Insurance Regulation determines the premium…

Why Do I Need Title Insurance When Purchasing Property?

  Title insurance, especially Owner’s title insurance, is extremely important when purchasing a house or piece of property. Yet many Buyers are unsure about what title insurance is and what it protects against. Here are some answers to the more common questions about title insurance. There are two types of title insurance: Lenders title insurance,…

Is My Buyer’s Deposit at Risk? Feasibility Study Period Under the Vacant Land Contract

Q: MY BUYER DIDN’T GET HIS SURVEY UNTIL AFTER THE FEASIBILITY STUDY PERIOD. IS MY BUYER’S DEPOSIT AT RISK IF THERE ARE SURVEY PROBLEMS UNDER THE FLORIDA REALTOR’S VACANT LAND CONTRACT?  A: It depends on whether the survey problem qualifies as a survey defect under buyer’s contract.  Most likely, the survey problem will qualify as…

Title Insurance 101

Title insurance, especially Owner’s title insurance, is extremely important when purchasing a house or piece of property. Yet many Buyers are unsure about what title insurance is and what it protects against. Here are some answers to the more common questions about title insurance. There are two types of title insurance: Lenders title insurance, which…

Can Buyer Object to an Encroachment on Prior Survey?

Question: Can the Buyer object to an encroachment shown in Seller’s prior survey, or does the Buyer need to obtain a new survey? The Buyer really needs to get a new survey. Under Paragraph 9(d) of both, the Regular and As-Is Florida Realtors/Florida Bar (“FR/BAR”) contract forms, survey is defined as: “Buyer may, at Buyer’s expense,…

Flood Insurance Reform Act of 2012

In 2012, Congress passed the Biggert-Waters Flood Insurance Reform Act of 2012 (“Act”) which requires FEMA, as well as other agencies, to change the way the National Flood Insurance Programs (“NFIP”) is run. The Act was designed to reduce the NFIP’s growing debt. Key provisions of the legislation require the NFIP to raise rates to…

Don’t Forget the Open Permit Search!

For financial reasons most parties do not perform an Open Permit search (which would include expired permits) until after the inspection period has expired.  This is a common mistake that generally leads to the buyers inability to object to an open permit issue at a later date.  The new FARBAR-2 Residential Contract for Purchase and…

Marketable Vs. Insurable Title

In response to our blog last week, most of the feedback we received involved questions pertaining to the quality of title that one might get if they acquire REO Property. The answer to this question is not simple. In a non-REO setting, the requirement is generally for the seller to deliver marketable title (i.e. title…

Should I use An Attorney Rather Than A Title Company For Closing?

In Florida, both, attorneys and title companies, may issue title insurance.  In contrast, in some states, like Delaware, only attorneys may issue title insurance.  The title insurance rates are promulgated by the Department of Insurance so title insurance obtained through an attorney is priced the same as from a title company.  In addition, closing costs…
Menu