You send a “sure, whatever works!” text from a showing at 9 p.m. Two years later, it’s Exhibit C. In Florida real estate disputes, emails, and texts are often the best evidence in the case: timestamped, specific, and hard to explain away. Here’s how to keep yours from working against you.
The Dos
- Do write every message as if a judge will read it. Because one might. Stay professional and factual.
- Do confirm verbal agreements in writing. A quick “Confirming our call: seller will repair the roof before closing” beats a he-said, she-said any day. Also check your contract’s notice provisions, since a text may not count as valid notice.
- Do keep the whole thread. Context helps you. Under Florida’s Evidence Code, a party’s own statements can generally be used against them, so you want the full conversation, not just the one line the other side likes.
- Do preserve everything once a dispute is brewing. You have a duty to keep relevant communications once litigation is reasonably anticipated. Turn off auto-delete and back up your phone before upgrading it.
- Do use your brokerage’s approved platforms. Florida law requires brokers to retain transaction records for years (Chapter 475), and “it’s somewhere on my old phone” is not a retention policy.
- Do call an attorney early. Before you respond to a demand letter or clean up your inbox.

The Don’ts
- Don’t delete messages once a dispute arises. The cover-up is usually worse than the text. Courts can impose sanctions for spoliation, and deleted messages are often recoverable anyway.
- Don’t use disappearing-message apps for business. They tend to look like evidence destruction when things go sideways.
- Don’t assume “it’s just a text” means “it’s not binding.” Electronic records and signatures carry legal weight. Texts can be evidence of an agreement, an amendment, or a waiver.
- Don’t hide known defects, in writing or otherwise. Under Johnson v. Davis, sellers must disclose known material defects that aren’t readily observable. A message showing who knew what, and when, is often the star of a nondisclosure case.
- Don’t edit, crop, or cherry-pick. Doctored screenshots wreck credibility fast. Keep the originals.
- Don’t give legal advice by text. “Don’t worry about that clause” can become a misrepresentation claim. Refer legal questions to an attorney.
- Don’t record calls without consent. Florida is a two-party consent state, so an unauthorized recording can create liability, not evidence.
Conclusion
Every message you send is a potential exhibit, so write accordingly, document key agreements, preserve everything once trouble appears, and get counsel involved early. Your future self, sitting in a deposition, will thank you. If you’re unsure what to write or what to save, please consult with a qualified, licensed Florida attorney.