Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
A man in a suit stands before a blurred phone with chat bubbles. Text promo for Florida Real Estate Litigation blog by Mark C. Mann, Esq., discussing key Emails and Texts at Berlin Patten Ebling Attorneys at Law.

Your Texts Are Testimony: Emails, Texts, and Florida Real Estate Litigation

You send a “sure, whatever works!” text from a showing at 9 p.m. Two years later, it’s Exhibit C. In Florida real estate disputes, emails, and texts are often the best evidence in the case: timestamped, specific, and hard to explain away. Here’s how to keep yours from working against you.

The Dos

  1. Do write every message as if a judge will read it. Because one might. Stay professional and factual.
  2. Do confirm verbal agreements in writing. A quick “Confirming our call: seller will repair the roof before closing” beats a he-said, she-said any day. Also check your contract’s notice provisions, since a text may not count as valid notice.
  3. Do keep the whole thread. Context helps you. Under Florida’s Evidence Code, a party’s own statements can generally be used against them, so you want the full conversation, not just the one line the other side likes.
  4. Do preserve everything once a dispute is brewing. You have a duty to keep relevant communications once litigation is reasonably anticipated. Turn off auto-delete and back up your phone before upgrading it.
  5. Do use your brokerage’s approved platforms. Florida law requires brokers to retain transaction records for years (Chapter 475), and “it’s somewhere on my old phone” is not a retention policy.
  6. Do call an attorney early. Before you respond to a demand letter or clean up your inbox.

    A hand holds a smartphone with blue chat bubbles on a dark screen. Caption reads: Texts and emails can be evidence of an agreement or amendment in Florida real estate litigation. Berlin Patten Ebling Attorneys at Law logo is at the top.

The Don’ts

  1. Don’t delete messages once a dispute arises. The cover-up is usually worse than the text. Courts can impose sanctions for spoliation, and deleted messages are often recoverable anyway.
  2. Don’t use disappearing-message apps for business. They tend to look like evidence destruction when things go sideways.
  3. Don’t assume “it’s just a text” means “it’s not binding.” Electronic records and signatures carry legal weight. Texts can be evidence of an agreement, an amendment, or a waiver.
  4. Don’t hide known defects, in writing or otherwise. Under Johnson v. Davis, sellers must disclose known material defects that aren’t readily observable. A message showing who knew what, and when, is often the star of a nondisclosure case.
  5. Don’t edit, crop, or cherry-pick. Doctored screenshots wreck credibility fast. Keep the originals.
  6. Don’t give legal advice by text. “Don’t worry about that clause” can become a misrepresentation claim. Refer legal questions to an attorney.
  7. Don’t record calls without consent. Florida is a two-party consent state, so an unauthorized recording can create liability, not evidence.

Conclusion

Every message you send is a potential exhibit, so write accordingly, document key agreements, preserve everything once trouble appears, and get counsel involved early. Your future self, sitting in a deposition, will thank you.  If you’re unsure what to write or what to save, please consult with a qualified, licensed Florida attorney.

Picture of Mark C. Mann, Esq.

Mark C. Mann, Esq.

Mark focuses his practice on representing individuals in civil litigation including personal injury and wrongful deaths, real estate disputes, contract disputes, contested probate matters, and family law cases.

Newsletter Sign Up

Here's How It Works:

Simple Submission: Using Payload, you can send your EMD funds. The platform is designed to ensure your transaction is both secure and hassle-free.

Transparent Fee Structure: A nominal processing fee of $12.00 will be applied to your transaction. This fee is disclosed during the submission process.

Instant Confirmation: Once your transaction is completed, you’ll receive an immediate confirmation email from Payload. Our accounting team will also be promptly notified, usually within minutes of the transfer.

Specifically for EMD: Payload is exclusively for submitting your Earnest Money Deposit ONLY. It is not to be used for final closing proceeds or any other payments.

Deposit Limit: To maintain the integrity of our process, we have set a maximum deposit amount of $100,000.00 for EMD submissions.